Original setup 2 years ago: I had 2 Identical Maxtor SATA 150 160GB HD's. About a year ago 1 died and I lost all my data on it.

Fast forward to now, about 2 months ago I bought a new Seagate SATA 150 200GB HD. I installed it on the SATA 2 position. Everything working fine.

Problem: Whenever I copy data of any kind from my Maxtor to the Seagate directly, about 10% of the files become corrupted during the transfer. If I copy the files to a CD first then copy them to the Seagate, no problems. Or if Install a program from CD to the Seagate no problems. It's only direct HD to HD transfers that this corruption occurs.

Anybody know why? Never happened with my old Maxtor's.